Which Exchange Rate Should You Use When Splitting a Trip?

By MarkUpdated 5 min read

Nobody argues about this until the trip is over. Then one person points out that the yen moved 4% while you were away, and suddenly a settled bill is not settled.

Why I needed this comparison

On a March 2025 Japan trip with three friends, I paid for three hotel nights in TWD before departure. Friends covered Lawson and coffee purchases for me in JPY cash during the trip. Those are two different kinds of receipts in one group settlement. I do not have a verified rate or amount to publish from that trip, so the arithmetic below uses clearly marked examples.

For an old trip like that, today’s reference rate is not the historical rate we actually faced. If the group agrees to use statement amounts or an expense-date rate, calculate that amount first and enter it in the settlement currency. BillSmart’s automatic conversion uses the latest available provider rate when the pair is first needed, and shows a short, two-decimal approximation alongside the payment.

The problem, stated plainly

On a week in Japan, three friends from Taiwan spend across two currencies. One paid for the hotel in yen on a card. One withdrew yen in cash at an ATM and paid for meals. One booked the flights months earlier in Taiwan dollars.

Every one of those transactions has a different exchange rate attached to it, and none of them is “the” rate. To settle up you have to choose one convention and apply it to everyone. The choice matters less than you think, but only if you make it deliberately and tell the group.

Four rates that all have a claim to being correct

1. A reference rate on the day of the expense

A published reference rate gives the group one number that does not depend on any traveller’s card. BillSmart instead fetches the latest available rate when a pair is first needed; it does not look up the expense date. Its sources are European Central Bank reference data where the ECB publishes it, and a second public source for the currencies it does not. New Taiwan dollars are in the second group, so the trip above settles on the fallback rather than on ECB data.

It avoids favouring the person who happened to use a particular card. Keep the original and converted amount so everybody can check the settlement later. The short rate shown by BillSmart is rounded for readability; its conversion uses the full provider rate.

2. The rate your card actually charged

The one on your statement. It is the true cost to the person who paid, which is exactly why it feels fairest to them and unfairest to everyone else. Two people buying identical dinners on the same night with different cards will produce different “true” numbers, because one card carries a foreign transaction fee of a few percent and the other does not.

If the group shares statement costs, agree whether card fees are shared too. Otherwise different cards can make identical purchases cost different amounts.

3. The rate on the day you settle up

Simple, and defensible if the group settles quickly. Its flaw shows up on long trips: if the currency moves significantly between the expense and the settlement, people who spent early and people who spent late are treated differently for no reason connected to what they bought.

4. One fixed rate for the whole trip, agreed in advance

Underrated. Before you leave, look up the rate and round it to something memorable, 1 TWD to 4.7 JPY, say. Everyone uses that number for everything.

It is not the most accurate method. The advantage is that anyone at the table can do the maths on a napkin. BillSmart has no manual rate field. Calculate and settle amounts using that fixed rate outside the tool, keeping the original foreign-currency receipts with your group’s transfer records.

What to actually do

A simple default: agree to use the same published reference rate method for everyone. Decide separately whether card and cash withdrawal fees stay with the payer or become shared expenses.

Two exceptions worth making consciously:

  • One person fronted a very large booking. If someone put NT$120,000 of flights on a card and ate a 1.5% fee doing it, that fee is NT$1,800, no longer noise. Add it as its own line item shared by the group. Enter it as a separate expense rather than fudging the rate.
  • The currency moved sharply mid-trip. If the difference would materially change what a friend owes, agree on a rate date before settling.

Traps that cost more than the rate you picked

Dynamic currency conversion

The card terminal asks whether you would like to be charged in your home currency instead of the local one. That option lets the merchant’s payment processor set the exchange rate and may add a markup or fee. Compare the disclosed terms with your card’s terms; choosing the local currency avoids the offered DCC conversion.

The same prompt appears at ATMs abroad: “with conversion” or “without conversion”. Check the displayed rate and fees before choosing.

Assuming the rate is fixed the moment you tap

It usually is not. Card networks convert when the transaction settles, which can be a day or several later. That is why the amount on your statement rarely matches the rate you looked up at dinner, even before fees.

Cash withdrawal fees hiding inside a good rate

An ATM can give a perfectly reasonable exchange rate and still cost you, because the withdrawal fee is charged separately, sometimes by both your bank and the machine’s operator. If one person is the group’s designated cash machine, those fees should be a shared expense, not a private tax on being helpful.

Agree on it in the group chat, before you fly

Two sentences can settle the rule: “Everything settles in TWD using the latest available reference rate when we calculate. Card fees stay with whoever paid them.” This matches BillSmart’s automatic conversion. If you agree on expense-date rates instead, calculate those amounts separately first.

The BillSmart calculator does not retrieve historical expense-date rates. When your group agrees to its latest available reference rate, enter each payment in the currency actually charged; the tool keeps the original and converted amount. For a historical or manually agreed rate, calculate and settle separately from the original receipts. Entering only the converted amount as a new payment would misstate the currency in the PDF.

Related reading

Worked example

The convention above, applied: one settlement currency for the whole group, every entry converted into it. This illustration uses fixed converted amounts so the rounding is easy to check; it is not a quote of today’s exchange rates.

Ana’s payment converts to TWD 4,785, Ben’s to TWD 4,128, and Chloe pays TWD 2,600. All three payments cover all three people. The total is TWD 11,513, split as TWD 3,838 for Ana, TWD 3,838 for Ben, and TWD 3,837 for Chloe. The one-dollar remainder follows the people list.

After subtracting each person’s share from what they paid, Chloe owes TWD 1,237. She sends TWD 947 to Ana and TWD 290 to Ben. Enter the original payment currencies in BillSmart; the exact converted values will depend on the latest available rate when you make the calculation.

Sources and scope

Reference rates are informational and may differ from the rate on a bank statement. See the ECB exchange-rate methodology and ExchangeRate-API update schedule. BillSmart keeps conversions during the current calculation and does not retrieve a historical expense date.

For card conversions, Visa explains the exchange rate and additional fees disclosed with dynamic currency conversion. Compare those terms with your own card agreement. The splitting rules in this guide are suggestions for your group, not universal bank or merchant rules.